My Favorite Pie Dough

873 Views 9 Comments

Pie is probably my favorite food group. Yes, it is a food group. And, yes, I have promised to deliver mouthwatering and nutritious recipes to you and your families at home. But, one of my healthy eating philosophies is that sometimes, you have to have wiggle room to stay on the wagon.

If for you that means scarfing down a few chocolate morsels on a rare occasion, throwing back a glass of champagne every now and then, or digging into a pile of nachos once in a blue moon…I say have at it. Hey, I told you I wasn’t a nutritionist!

For me, living a little means diving into a piece of flaky, buttery and sweet pie. Probably with a fair obscene amount of homemade whipped cream piled on top.

You just can’t have good pie without good crust. Miss AK rule. I’ll be sharing numerous pie recipes in the future, and this will aways be the standard vessel that I’ll link back to. I think it deserves its own post because making perfect pie dough is very simple, but there is some science to it that needs to be explained.

This is not my personal recipe, I have been using the All-Purpose Buttery Pie Dough out of the Complete Book of Pies cookbook for years.

This pie crust is sweeter and thicker than some, but still incredibly flaky. If you haven’t heard yet, the secret to flaky pie dough is freezing cold fat and liquid. You’ll also want to heed my advice when I tell you to place the raw dough in the fridge before you roll it out, and once again after it has been pressed into the pie dish. The changes in temperature are what cause the crust to have that delicate texture.

Photo Nov 28, 2 02 45 PM

To start, place your refrigerated butter in the freezer for about 15 min. Pour water into a glass or bowl filled with ice. In the meantime, measure out your flour, sugar, and salt. Give these a quick mix to distribute.

Photo Nov 28, 2 06 30 PM

When I have a food processor on hand, I like to use that to make my dough. If not, a good, old-fashioned pastry cutter or fork will work fine. Cut your freezing butter into small cubes. Begin to work the butter into the dough, or pulse your food processor until the mixture looks like pea-sized crumbs. Start adding your water tablespoon by tablespoon, until the dough pulls together into a ball.

Photo Nov 28, 2 10 39 PM

This should not be sticky, but it should hold together well without crumbling. Divide the dough in half, form into a ball, and flatten with your hand to make a disc. Wrap this tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for a least 20 mins. This can be refrigerated for 24 hours, or at this stage you can place the wrapped dough into freezer bags and freeze them for a rainy day. This recipe makes two crusts, so if you aren’t making a covered pie, you can freeze one disc and use the other right away.

Photo Nov 28, 2 12 46 PM

Pull your dough out of the refrigerator and let it come to room temp. Flour a work surface, your dough, and a rolling pin lightly.

Photo May 06, 1 42 40 PM

Roll your dough out. You should place your pie plate in the center of the rolled dough to make sure you have at least 2-3 inches of extra dough around the plate to form your rolled edge. Fold the dough in half once and once more (like you are making a pizza slice). Place the tip of your dough into the center of the pie plate. Unfold. Trim the overhanging edges so they are even, and tuck them under. Pinch your dough between your thumb and pointer finger, pressing with your opposite pointer finger to make a crimped edge. Or, you can always press your dough with a fork! Place the pie back in the fridge for at least 20-30 mins before adding your filling and baking.

.Photo May 27, 11 43 49 AM

Remove the crust from the fridge, pour in the desired filling and bake following the instructions listed on the recipe you’re using. If you need a baked shell, pierce the dough with a fork so that air is not trapped between the plate and dough; trapped air causes your crust to bubble and shrink. You’ll also need to weigh it down in the center to prevent the bubbling. When I’m baking a shell, I always weigh it down with pie weights. You can find these: here. If you don’t want to invest, line your pie with parchment paper and weigh it by pouring beans or rice onto the parchment.

To fully bake the shell, put it in a 375 degree oven for 20-25 mins.

For a first-time pie baker, I know this can seem daunting. After your first few pies, you’ll see they are actually pretty easy to assemble, and I promise you’ll fall in love with them as much as I have.

Photo May 27, 11 45 16 AM

As always, I love to help you troubleshoot-please feel free to send me a message in the Contact Me section above!


Miss AK

5.0 from 1 reviews
My Favorite Pie Dough
Recipe type: Sweet Treat
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 2 crusts
  • 3 cups of AP Flour
  • 1 cup of cold, unsalted butter
  • ¼ cup of sugar
  • ½ tsp of salt
  • 6-8 tbsp of ice cold water
  1. Place butter into freezer 15 mins before using.
  2. Fill a glass or bowl with ice water. Let chill.
  3. Measure out dry ingredients. Mix.
  4. Cube butter. Add it to dry mixture.
  5. Incorporate with food processor, pastry cutter or fork until pea-sized crumbs form.
  6. Add water 1 tbsp at a time until dough pulls together.
  7. Divide the dough in half. Wrap each half in plastic wrap.
  8. Refrigerate 20 mins.
  9. Let dough come to room temp, roll out.
  10. Lay crust into pie plate.
  11. Refrigerate again.
  12. For recipes that call for a cooked pie shell ONLY: bake for 20-25 mins at 375 degrees

*this post has not been sponsored by any of the products I have linked above. I’m simply passing on helpful product recommendations for your personal use.

  • Megan - The Emotional Baker


    I love making pie! I wish I always had extra dough in the fridge for emergency pie 😉 I have to try your recipe soon!

    • Miss Allie

      Oh my goodness, totally let me know when you try!!! I’d love to hear what you think of the recipe! xoxx

  • Laura Clevenger


    Adding to my recipe book. Can I freeze these if I make a handful at a time? How long do you think the freezer life is on these guys?

    • allmcd3

      Yayyy! You found it! Absolutely, you can freeze them. The crust makes enough for a covered pie, so you can technically make 2 pies from each recipe. I often freeze half of the dough, and I’ve used it even 6 months after making it if it doesn’t get freezer burnt! I’ll warn you: I like making one batch at a time as opposed to doubling the recipe. It really overloads the food processor and sometimes it doesn’t mix correctly. Sometimes, I’ll make a few batches in October and November and I’m good to go for the holidays!

  • Jess


    Question! Have you tried this recipe with the Gluten Free 1 to 1 flour at all? Just wondering if it will be too crumbly to roll or if it will actually work. Looks delicious though!

    • allmcd3

      I haven’t tried it yet!!!! I would definitely recommend using a mix like Gluten Free 1 to 1 flour and using the same amount of butter, sugar, salt, and water. I’ll have to break into gluten free crusts soon!!!

Leave a Comment

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge

Join the newsletter

Subscribe to get our latest content by email.
We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit